When American Pie debuted in theaters, it revolutionized the comedy genre. This bold, raunchy teen comedy resonated with a new generation like never before.

The successful sequel further cemented its status as a comedic icon for early 2000s teens. However, over time, numerous spin-offs, direct-to-DVD releases, and failed legacy sequels transformed this once-great franchise into a shadow of its former self.

So, what led to the decline of American Pie, and is there hope for reviving its legacy?